PDA

View Full Version : Studder/stall after driving



Tim Smith
05-22-2009, 10:06 AM
This is so annoying. I've been tuning up here and there but this problem has me stumped.

The points are freshly cleaned with a little bit of sand paper and well adjusted. I've opened up the carb (Weber 34 ICH) and didn't find any debris. All in all the thing idles just perfectly around 700 rpm, until I go for a drive.

Driving along, sometimes I can feel it missing. When this happens and you hold the throttle and rpm at just before overrun (not really accelerating or decelerating) you can feel the motor bucking and missing. When that bucking condition happens I know that it will stall out when I get to the next stop sign. If it doesn't stall out then it will be running terribly as I'm two footing it to keep it going.

When it does stall out, I'll restart it and it will run perfectly again. Well until I start driving it again. :confused:

Any thoughts from the group?

kevin-ct
05-22-2009, 10:38 AM
fuel filter? if you need help I can stop by this weekend.

Tim Smith
05-22-2009, 10:52 AM
You might be on to something Kevin. I do have one ready to pop in and to tell you the truth, I forgot about it... :o

Thanks!

Andrew IIA
05-22-2009, 12:51 PM
You need driving gloves !

(private joke for tim), A

Tim Smith
05-22-2009, 01:22 PM
Neck and neck, battling up the hill. Sweat beading off my forehead. Smoke barreling into the cabin. My passenger leaning into it, gesturing the shear madness of it all. Up comes the next bend and I'm sure I'll have this one. Gearbox whining as I'm quite possibly squeezing every inch of torque out of this thundering block. It's a blind turn heading our way and this race of chicken is at full tilt. I glance over to Andrew hoping steal that look of fear and desperation that I'm surely conveying at this very moment.

What do I see? Oh nothing special. Just Andrew calmly down shifting and perhaps reaching for a sip of tea (little finger raised). His dogs looking at me from the back as if I'm giving them a show.

You may have beaten me this time Andrew, but next time I'm wearing driving gloves.

ktom300
05-22-2009, 03:46 PM
Try your condensor. Mine was flaky and no matter how much I sanded the points I couldn't get it to run past idle.

adkrover
05-23-2009, 03:30 PM
Try also to clean the inside of the cap and the contacts of the cap and rotor. If they are caked with gunk that can make a weak spark of if there is a lot of carbon floating around in there it can cause the spark to arc across to a different plug. Really plays heck with a proper firing order.

Jeff Aronson
05-23-2009, 06:39 PM
This happened to me once; check your hose from the air cleaner to the carb. If the inside is loose it will close up under the pressure from the carb intake. Try running the car without the hose.

Are you sure you don't have water in your gas? Have you removed the fuel pump sediment bowl to check for water? That would cause the same symptoms as you're describing.

The condensor is a good tip also. Try replacing the current one with your old one [they rarely go "bad"] but I've also experienced similar symptoms with a bad condensor. It's the only one in 19 years of Land Rover ownership, but there you go.

Lastly, when this happens again, feel the coil. It should be warm but not hot to touch. A coil breaking down inside will also produce the bucking under load, but the car will often start fine for a while.

Let us know what you find.

Jeff

Wallace
05-27-2009, 12:42 PM
I had a similar problem with my 109 on a trip from RI to VA. Every now and then, it would miss and die at speed only to restart and run fine at idle. Sounds like fuel, right? I replaced the filter, blew out the lines and disassembled the carb - all at the side of the road. Several times, in fact (CT, NY, NJ, MD). The points, condenser, cap and wires were all new, but proven. I checked them all anyway but couldn't find an electrical problem. Eventually, it died completely and had to be towed the last 8 miles. Embarrassing, but I had run out of ideas.

The fix turned out to be quite simple. The short ground wire inside the distributor (the one that grounds the points to the distributor housing) had a break inside its fabric covering. It ran fine at idle. But when the vacuum advance started rotating the plate, the ground wire would change position slightly and the points would lose their ground.

Might be worth checking.

kevin-ct
05-28-2009, 09:21 AM
Hey Tim, Did you find the cause?

Tim Smith
05-28-2009, 09:58 AM
Hi everyone,
These are all great thoughts. I haven't had time to actually look at the truck yet but am planning to figure it out tonight. Hoping to get this fixed and ready for my next road trip starting tomorrow night. :rolleyes:

I'll be sure to post up the details of my findings.

kevin-ct
05-28-2009, 10:11 AM
Tim, if you need help I can stop by tonight.

Road trip, where?

Tim Smith
05-28-2009, 11:23 AM
Hey Kevin,
If you are up for it, shoot for 6:00 pm as I should be well into it by then.

I'll tell you all about the beer run too. :p

Tim Smith
05-28-2009, 09:01 PM
So it's not the fuel filter, carb, wires cap or plugs. Not the points and not the fuel pump.

I've had to quit for the night but I'm going to check the condensor and that little ground wire tomorrow.

I did take it for a drive and at least I've got the timing and carb set up right. Good power (under throttle even if it's acting up) and no pinging. As a test, I drove it until I could feel it acting up. When I would come to a stop sign it would either die or run terrible.

However, if I knew it was running badly and I was coming to a stop, I flicked the ignition off and on again real quick just before coming to the stop. When I did that it ran beautifully! Tried it a couple of times and it seemed to do the trick. Does this sound like a condensor? I have to admit that I need to read up on that little piece of kit.

SafeAirOne
05-28-2009, 09:54 PM
So it's not the fuel filter, carb, wires cap or plugs. Not the points and not the fuel pump.

I flicked the ignition off and on again real quick just before coming to the stop. When I did that it ran beautifully! Tried it a couple of times and it seemed to do the trick. Does this sound like a condensor? I have to admit that I need to read up on that little piece of kit.

The function of the condensor is to briefly give the electricity someplace to go when the points open. If the condensor wasn't there "absorbing" the electricity when the points opened (or was defective), the electricity would just spark across the points even though they were open. This arcing would have the same effect as the points staying closed. That is to say that the magnetic field around the primary winding in the coil would never collapse and energize the secondary winding, which drives the spark plugs. End result: the engine won't run, or won't run properly.


Condensors are cheap. It couldn't hurt to replace it. After that, What's left? The ignition switch, the power wires to the ignition switch, the wire to the coil, the coil, the primary wire to the points, and the points ground.

EDIT: A fairly decent description of the ignition system component functions can be found here (http://www.mattsauto.com/i.htm).

Tim Smith
05-28-2009, 10:15 PM
Thanks Mark. I did look through the forum for the other related threads but your link is probably the best description I've seen yet.

Tim Smith
06-01-2009, 10:43 AM
So I thought for sure it was going to be the condensor. I swapped in an old one and thought it was all fixed up. About half way through the road trip I had to pull off the highway and there was the issue again. Dang! :(

When I had a chance, I pulled over and took a look. As I was under the hood fiddling with the wires, I put my hand on the trigger wire that goes between the distributor and the coil. Interestingly enough, I got a jolt as if I had just grabbed a high tension lead. Hmm, that ain't right. :confused:

I pushed on through the rest of the trip as it was raining and I didn't feel like getting soaked in the dark, on the side of the road. Next morning I dropped in an old coil I had brought along and all is well again.

It was the coil! :)

Thanks again everyone for your thoughts on this one. Sometimes with a rover, it takes a village. ;)

SafeAirOne
06-01-2009, 01:13 PM
I pushed on through the rest of the trip as it was raining and I didn't feel like getting soaked in the dark, on the side of the road. Next morning I dropped in an old coil I had brought along and all is well again.

It was the coil! :)

Thanks again everyone for your thoughts on this one. Sometimes with a rover, it takes a village. ;)

Hmm...Did you change all the igntion wires lately? I'm not sure how a faulty coil will transmit high voltage down the exterior of a good ignition wire, but if that fixes it, then OK!

Often, however, the high-voltage ignition wire insulation will break down with time (or a wire will be damaged) and will work perfectly until the air becomes damp or it rains or you run through a big puddle, then will begin to leak, causing the engine to run poorly. You can sometimes detect this while looking under the bonnet after dark and see some arcing on the wires.

EDIT: Maybe I misunderstood--When you say "Trigger wire" is that the thin primary that goes from the coil to the points? If so, you're right-this could be a coil issue, as there should only be 12v there and shouldn't give too much of a jolt, (unless you used your tongue to grab it).

The "spray bottle full of water at night" troubleshooting method works good for this type of issue.

Tim Smith
06-01-2009, 01:24 PM
Thanks Mark but it wasn't the high tension leads that gave me the jolt but the low voltage wire connecting the coil to the points. I think something went foobar inside the coil which was making it happen.

The fact that it was raining probably had nothing to do with this particular case because I'd been experiencing this issue in the dry as well.

SafeAirOne
06-01-2009, 01:31 PM
Thanks Mark but it wasn't the high tension leads that gave me the jolt but the low voltage wire connecting the coil to the points. I think something went foobar inside the coil which was making it happen.

The fact that it was raining probably had nothing to do with this particular case because I'd been experiencing this issue in the dry as well.

Yep--I tried to edit my post when I re-read "trigger wire" in you description. The thin primary wire shouldn't be giving you any jolt, unless you're grabbing it with your tongue.:)

Donnie
06-02-2009, 06:45 PM
The function of the condensor is to briefly give the electricity someplace to go when the points open. If the condensor wasn't there "absorbing" the electricity when the points opened (or was defective), the electricity would just spark across the points even though they were open. This arcing would have the same effect as the points staying closed. That is to say that the magnetic field around the primary winding in the coil would never collapse and energize the secondary winding, which drives the spark plugs. End result: the engine won't run, or won't run properly.


Condensors are cheap. It couldn't hurt to replace it. After that, What's left? The ignition switch, the power wires to the ignition switch, the wire to the coil, the coil, the primary wire to the points, and the points ground.

EDIT: A fairly decent description of the ignition system component functions can be found here (http://www.mattsauto.com/i.htm).
If the hi tension tower on the coil has a carbon track or a tiny crack, secondary voltage can transverse into the primary wire and cause you problems, altho U said that the points were ok, that U sanded them, A point file is a bit more sanitary in cleaning points. I.E., no alum oxide or silicon carbide to get in the program. NOT nit picking your procedure, just a bit of trivia.....................Nader

Donnie
06-02-2009, 06:50 PM
Thanks Mark but it wasn't the high tension leads that gave me the jolt but the low voltage wire connecting the coil to the points. I think something went foobar inside the coil which was making it happen.

The fact that it was raining probably had nothing to do with this particular case because I'd been experiencing this issue in the dry as well.
More useless trivia: if your points are turning blue, your resistance is faulty, points should be grey..........if your points are transferring metal from one contact to the other suspect a faulty condensor