Still considering longer front shackles on my SIII 109"

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bullstanky
    1st Gear
    • Dec 2007
    • 119

    Still considering longer front shackles on my SIII 109"

    Ever since I swapped the stock springs out for parabolics in my SIII 109" 3-door, my Rover has been about 1-2" taller in the rear than in the front. This is likely because I chose the 4 leaf heavy duty parabolics for the rear which provided more lift than in the front. I only chose the 4 leaf springs cause they were labeled as heavy duty...I couldn't resist.

    Initially the extra lift in the rear caused my rear drive shaft to clunk inside of the rear crossmember. With new engine and transmission mounts and a new shaft, this was eliminated.

    My rover is going under the knife pretty soon--the front crossmember is rusted out and the steering unit is caput, so my shop is going to cut out the front horn and weld in a replacement that I've found, and then the whole steering system (hopefully with the exception of the steering column) will be rebuilt--new steering unit, all new tie rod ends and new damper.

    While this work is being done and the front end is out, I figure it is a good time to try and gain an inch or so of ride height in the front to try and level my rover out. I've read of the many potential issues of adding longer 1-ton military shackles to the rear of the front springs--pushing the front drive unit down and forward & messing up the geometry, which can bind or cause wear to u-joints and pinions or cause the shaft to hit the crossmember, and which can only be eliminated with shimming. The option to avoid these problems is to modify the front spring hangers to drop the front spring about an inch so that the spring remains level and geometry unchanged.

    It seems like I'm in the perfect place to go ahead and have my shop modify the front spring hangers on my new replacement front horn (once it has been welded in) to compensate for the longer 1-ton shackles being added to the rear of the front springs.

    So here is the question--should I have them hack and weld and fab the front spring hangers on the new horn to get the desired leveling of the spring, or can I have them simply fab (or repurpose/modify the shorter shackles that I'll be replacing) shackles for the front of the springs to level them out?

    The other option is to remove the 4 leaf hd rear parabolics and replace them with the regular 3 leaf ones, hoping that brings the rear down some, but since I'm already having my shop rebuild the front end, and already have the 4 leafs installed and ironed out in the rear, it would seem counter productive.

    What do you fellas think?
    Last edited by bullstanky; 03-06-2013, 05:58 PM.
    '75 SIII 109 Diesel - I'm in deep.
  • TeriAnn
    Overdrive
    • Nov 2006
    • 1087

    #2
    Setting the front suspension up to raise the suspension & leaving the rear stock? What do you do when the rear parabolics wear out?

    If you want to add an inch height in the front get a set of 109 military extended shackles for the front and add a 6 degree wedge between the axle housing and the front spring to move the kingpin angle back to where it is supposed to be.

    If you can find 109 military front spring brackets, install them both front and rear. These brackets come with 2 mounting holes. The one closest to the frame is for use with civilian shackles. The lower one is for use with military long shackles. You could use the lower mounting hole AND extended shackles on the front & civilian on the rear until the rear springs wear out. The put the right springs under your truck and use the same shackles front & rear.

    I really think you should swap out the rear springs & do things right.

    For leaf springs "heavy duty" means they are designed to carry more weight, not that they are more rugged. The weight of the truck does not compress the springs as much on heavy duty springs so the vehicle sits higher and the ride is stiffer. If you are over sprung the springs will not flex like they would with the weight they were designed to carry. Your 4 leaf springs will give you a stiffer ride than the correct rear springs.

    Don't feel alone you are not the first nor the last to make that mistake. You can ask the people you purchased the springs from if you can safely remove a leaf
    Last edited by TeriAnn; 03-07-2013, 12:24 PM.
    -

    Teriann Wakeman_________
    Flagstaff, AZ.




    1960 Land Rover Dormobile, owned since 1978

    My Land Rover web site

    Comment

    • o2batsea
      Overdrive
      • Oct 2006
      • 1199

      #3
      To my mind, the 4 leaf parabolics are just too much. Unless you regularly haul around depleted uranium or big block Ford engines, you really don't need them. There are pretty stiff. I would take out a leaf. I was going to do that on mine, but alas never got to it.
      Even so I don't think that removing a spring will lower the back at all. You really need the longer shackles. Don't extend the frame horns. You can make custom shackles that will set up the truck level, but I think you want a little bit of rake for appearance's sake, cuz when you load it up it will sit too low in the rear.
      For the front, if you are going to the trouble of rebuilding the whole mess, I highly recommend that you convert to power steering. On a 109 it is almost mandatory. TeriAnn's pages have just about all the info you need. If I were doing it all again I would use a P38 steering box. It will be outboard of the frame which is a real handy place to have it. Mine currently has the RRC/D1 box and I am thinking of pulling it out in favor of the P38 one so my intercooler and radiator fit better.

      Comment

      • bullstanky
        1st Gear
        • Dec 2007
        • 119

        #4
        Originally posted by TeriAnn
        I really think you should swap out the rear springs & do things right.

        For leaf springs "heavy duty" means they are designed to carry more weight, not that they are more rugged. The weight of the truck does not compress the springs as much on heavy duty springs so the vehicle sits higher and the ride is stiffer. If you are over sprung the springs will not flex like they would with the weight they were designed to carry. Your 4 leaf springs will give you a stiffer ride than the correct rear springs.

        Don't feel alone you are not the first nor the last to make that mistake. You can ask the people you purchased the springs from if you can safely remove a leaf
        You're right--the correct thing to do is swap out 3 leaf rear springs for the 4 leaf H-D ones currently installed. In retrospect, I wish the folks who sold me the springs (not our host) would have recommended the 3 leaf springs when I ordered, or when I informed them of my ride height issue, rather than offering me the new rear dive shaft and engine/trans mounts that cured the rubbing of the drive shaft in the crossmember, but left me with too much spring, would have offered to swap for the 3 leaf ones. For the cost of what I paid to put the new engine/trans mounts and drive shaft in (albeit, that needed replacing anyhow) I could have put the new springs in and been set. But you live and you learn
        '75 SIII 109 Diesel - I'm in deep.

        Comment

        • bullstanky
          1st Gear
          • Dec 2007
          • 119

          #5
          So should I just remove a leaf (how is this done?) or buy a new $400 set of 3 leaf springs and try to sell the ones I have?
          '75 SIII 109 Diesel - I'm in deep.

          Comment

          • busboy
            2nd Gear
            • Nov 2012
            • 202

            #6
            Look for someone that wants to trade a 3 for a 4.
            1971 series 2a 88, series 3 trans, Fairey OD, owned since 1978.

            Comment

            • SalemRover
              3rd Gear
              • Aug 2007
              • 310

              #7
              I put parabolics on a military 109 rover (3 rear / 2 Front). Mounting to the military holes and shackles caused the rear propshaft to strike the frame on articulation. I cannot recall if the front had issues (doubt it). I run the civilian shackles and mounts now. If you are not comfortable removing a leaf find a spring shop and ask them to do it. My fronts sagged after 7 years and I had new super heavy duty 2 leafs made up at a spring shop for 75$ a whack.

              Jason

              Comment

              • o2batsea
                Overdrive
                • Oct 2006
                • 1199

                #8
                Originally posted by SalemRover
                I had new super heavy duty 2 leafs made up at a spring shop for 75$ a whack.
                This

                Comment

                • bullstanky
                  1st Gear
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 119

                  #9
                  Originally posted by SalemRover
                  I put parabolics on a military 109 rover (3 rear / 2 Front). Mounting to the military holes and shackles caused the rear propshaft to strike the frame on articulation. I cannot recall if the front had issues (doubt it). I run the civilian shackles and mounts now. If you are not comfortable removing a leaf find a spring shop and ask them to do it. My fronts sagged after 7 years and I had new super heavy duty 2 leafs made up at a spring shop for 75$ a whack.

                  Jason
                  Which of the 4 leaves do you remove ? Just cut it out?
                  '75 SIII 109 Diesel - I'm in deep.

                  Comment

                  • SalemRover
                    3rd Gear
                    • Aug 2007
                    • 310

                    #10
                    Originally posted by bullstanky
                    Which of the 4 leaves do you remove ? Just cut it out?
                    Honestly couldnt tell ya. That is a great question for the people that sold you the springs.

                    Jason

                    Comment

                    • bullstanky
                      1st Gear
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 119

                      #11
                      After much consideration, it seems like there's a right way, a wrong way, and then there's the way I'm going to do it.

                      Swapping out the four leaf springs for a 3 leaf pair seems like the right way. But would cost the most and leave me with an unneeded pair of springs to sell.

                      Cutting a leaf out of my four leaf springs (seeing as how I know nothing about how this is done or how it would affect the spring) seems like the wrong way, because I might spend a bunch of time just to ruin my springs, leaving me with one pair that is shot and needing to buy replacement 3 leaf springs.

                      Which brings be back to my initial plan of adding military shackles to the rear of the front spring and custom shackles to the front of the spring. All I have to buy is 4 military shackle plates (I have 2 sets of civilian plates I can customize and repurpose for the front of the springs) and hook it up. If/when either the front or rear springs end up sagging and I have to replace them, I can get the correct springs then and just remove my front shackle job.

                      It just seems like the shackle work is cheap, easy and reversible, and if it doesn't work it leaves me buying the new springs I probably needed all along anyway, and if it does work then I'm good to go until it's time for new springs.
                      '75 SIII 109 Diesel - I'm in deep.

                      Comment

                      • o2batsea
                        Overdrive
                        • Oct 2006
                        • 1199

                        #12
                        Shackles are nothing more than 1/4 plate with a threaded hole on one side. The longer ones I used to have had a bar welded in the middle to keep them in plane. You can have them made locally.

                        Comment

                        • I Leak Oil
                          Overdrive
                          • Nov 2006
                          • 1796

                          #13
                          Originally posted by bullstanky
                          After much consideration, it seems like there's a right way, a wrong way, and then there's the way I'm going to do it.
                          I was wondering how long this would go on. If I had to do work on the front of the frame anyway I'd do the same thing and you didn't say you were unhappy with the way the 4 leafers work or ride.

                          When reworking the front spring mounts I'd just suggest to keep the regular spring positon in addition to the new location in case you ever do go back to regular shackles. Only other things you might consider would be to extend your bump stops, brake lines and notch the engine cross member for the drive shaft.
                          Jason
                          "Clubs are for Chumps" Club president

                          Comment

                          • jac04
                            Overdrive
                            • Feb 2007
                            • 1884

                            #14
                            Originally posted by bullstanky

                            Which brings be back to my initial plan of adding military shackles to the rear of the front spring and custom shackles to the front of the spring.
                            You want to have a shackle located at both the front and back of the front springs? If so, that won't work. You need a fixed mounting point at the front of the spring. Maybe I'm not understanding exactly what it is you want to do at the front of the springs.

                            Comment

                            • I Leak Oil
                              Overdrive
                              • Nov 2006
                              • 1796

                              #15
                              Based on the original post I think it's just a misuse of nomeclature vs. his actual understanding of what he wants to do at the front of the spring.
                              Jason
                              "Clubs are for Chumps" Club president

                              Comment

                              Working...