Front frame horn rust...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • masonater
    3rd Gear
    • Nov 2007
    • 329

    Front frame horn rust...

    So the rear crossmember and one of the front frame horns are the only spots (pretty much) that are rusty. I know RN sells the replacement horns but just the spot where the bumper mounts is rotten, the rest is solid. Should i just cut out around the rust and fab in some new pieces? It seems simple in theory but im wondering if anyone else has had experience with this. Thanks.
    Last edited by masonater; 02-14-2011, 09:41 PM.
    1970 Series IIA 109 EX-MOD
    1971 Series IIA 109 EX-MOD
    1982 Mercedes 300TD
    1989 RRC
    1993 D110
    1994 RRC LWB
    1995 RRC SWB Brooklands Edition
    1995 RRC LWB
    1995 RRC LWB
    1995 Disco
    1996 GMC 2500 Suburban
    1996 Disco
    1997 Disco
    2001 RR P38
    2005 LR3 HSE
    2006 RR HSE
  • scott
    Overdrive
    • Oct 2006
    • 1226

    #2
    i'd fab, think of it as kind of a practice run at replacing the horn.
    '64 Series IIA 88 Canvas Tilt
    '68 Series IIA RHD Ambulance
    '76 Spitfire 1500
    '07 LR3 (Series Recovery Vehicle)

    Comment

    • superpowerdave
      Low Range
      • Aug 2009
      • 32

      #3
      Mine started out that way. And honestly, I'd be real surprised if the rust stopped right there at the front of the frame. Maybe it's just me, but it looks as though the top has already been replaced - my eyes aren't as good as they used to be mind you If it's already been patched I'd take a real close look at it.

      For piece of mind, since it is structural (I mean, the spring mounts right there!), I'd buy the replacement piece or have it done by a pro.

      When I specced it out, the cost of having one built outweighed the replacement; in the end I had an entire frame built ... but that was me.
      1964 SIIA 109 | 1973 SIII 88 | 1995 RRC | 2000 DII | 2000 P38

      Comment

      • TeriAnn
        Overdrive
        • Nov 2006
        • 1087

        #4
        Originally posted by masonater
        So the rear crossmember and one of the front frame horns are the only spots (pretty much) that are rusty. I know RN sells the replacement horns but just the spot where the bumper mounts is rotten, the rest is solid. Should i just cut out around the rust and fab in some new pieces? It seems simple in theory but im wondering if anyone else has had experience with this. Thanks.
        Sounds like your truck & mine have rust damage in the same spots with a solid frame in between. My rear cross member has a lot of rust at one end and the other end has been buckled from rock crawling damage & pounding back straight so it is real weak.

        The frame horns tend to rust right at the front. As it turns out, there is evidently a reinforcing cross piece inside the frame just a little behind where the bumper mounts. The cross piece keeps water & much that comes in at the holes at the top front from going back into the frame. So usually the rust is limited to the front of the frame to about where the front of the spring mount is located.

        I'm thinking of just having a fabricator who specializes in car frames just cut off my rusty end and build me a new front end. Though I may yet just buy new front horn sections and have them welded on. I need to cost estimate both options before making up my mind.
        -

        Teriann Wakeman_________
        Flagstaff, AZ.




        1960 Land Rover Dormobile, owned since 1978

        My Land Rover web site

        Comment

        • greenmeanie
          Overdrive
          • Oct 2006
          • 1358

          #5
          My 109 had similar issues. If the side plates and the spring mount are solid as they appear then I would just fabricate a repair. In my case I removed the internal crush plates for the bumper mount and replaced them with tube to sleeve the bolt holes. I also drilled a couple of small holes in the front of the repaired section to ensure any water that gets in there comes back out.

          Comment

          • 109 Pretender
            1st Gear
            • Oct 2008
            • 110

            #6
            frame horn replacement

            I'd agree w/others that repair might work fine. However, it appears you have the MOD frame that comes w/extended shackle plates and our host only sells the civie frame horn (I think). It might also be a "custom" job done by previous owner to gain ground clearance. Does anyone know where to get the military frame horns - I haven't been able to source repair pieces. Of course you could just get them fabbed locally as long as what you have to work with is to spec (i.e. MOD). If it's a home job - I'd take careful measurements and assess whether it's good enough to make a pattern from. Just a thought...

            Good luck!

            Comment

            • LaneRover
              Overdrive
              • Oct 2006
              • 1743

              #7
              If you have welding skills I would cut the rust out and re-fab as it is all straight stuff and pretty simple. The worst thing that happens is that you still have to buy a frame horn. But if the rest of it really is solid then fabbing up this section is the quickest, cheapest route in my opinion.

              Brent
              1958 107 SW - Sold to a better home
              1965 109 SW - nearly running well
              1966 88 SW - running but needing attention
              1969 109 P-UP

              http://www.facebook.com/album.php?ai...2&l=64cfe23aa2

              Comment

              • east high
                3rd Gear
                • Jan 2008
                • 337

                #8
                This must be fairly common as I had the same kind of rust damage on my rig. With the help of a friend, I cut out the bad and fabbed up a patch to replace it. Be sure to spray in some rust inhibitor and drill a drain hole in your new patch, or it's gonna start all over again..

                Originally posted by LaneRover
                If you have welding skills I would cut the rust out and re-fab as it is all straight stuff and pretty simple. The worst thing that happens is that you still have to buy a frame horn. But if the rest of it really is solid then fabbing up this section is the quickest, cheapest route in my opinion.

                Brent
                '67 sIIa 88

                Comment

                • belenjack
                  Low Range
                  • Dec 2006
                  • 11

                  #9
                  front frame horn rust

                  mason i have a frame horn on an old chassis you might be interested in to patch yours i also live in your town pm me to check it out its free for the cause jack

                  Comment

                  Working...