Transmission or Engine ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mrdoiron
    4th Gear
    • Dec 2009
    • 446

    Transmission or Engine ?

    I need some advice here please...on my 69 IIa.

    I recently had a u joint failure, following some transmission seal work done by a local transmission shop.

    So I took it back to them as I figured it could have been related (per a previous posting I had). Turns out that the yoke portion of the rear drive shaft had a chip out of it and as such wouldn't secure correctly the new u-joint - so a new rear shaft went in (from Rovers north of course). Not sure if that caused the older u joint to fall out, OR if the shaft clipped the ground when the u joint came out not sure... regardless, the issue here is a new one :

    While they had it, I told them that with the 'new seal kit' I had gave them for the transmission actually now drips even more...so "please check that also". So they did, re-sealed, shaft in - and home I went.

    I noticed NOW however, that there seems to be far less power in all gears... with minimal pull, although it does go and cycle through gears fine... feels kinda like starting in second and never really picking up enough speed or power like before. None of the gears have any significant power...And top speed if far less also.
    I moved it to low on the transfer and seems enough more pronounced in low with no real pull power ... is there a possibility they put it back together wrong yet still runs - geared lower ??? Or would this possibly be unrelated and something gone on the engine ?

    Stumped and looking for thoughts on what could be happening before I take it back. It does sound a little different also...

    appreciate some wisdom...

    mike
    ---------------------------
    1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
    1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
    1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
    1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
    1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
    2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
    2010 RR Sport Supercharged


    http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/
  • Apis Mellifera
    3rd Gear
    • Apr 2008
    • 386

    #2
    Sounds like they got the trans brake back on too tight. It's unlikely that you could disassemble a gearbox and reassemble it incorrectly such that it works fine mechanically, but somehow reduces performance in the way you describe. It appears to me to be a case of introduced drag. The most likely being an over-tight trans brake. If they (for some unnecessary reason) stripped the gearbox and TC to the bare case to replace the seals and gaskets, it's possible there is an end float problem (unlikely). So, I'd look at the trans brake first. It's the easiest to check too. This is assuming they didn't do any other work (timing adjustment, brake work). That would also cause sluggishness. I'm ignoring the possibility of the new prop shaft being stiff and needing to break-in. If it was stiff enough to cause the problem you've described, it would be faulty and apparent prior to installation.

    Does the problem lessen as the temp warms up and you get some heat in the drive line?
    © 1974 Apis Mellifera. Few rights preserved.

    Comment

    • Terrys
      Overdrive
      • May 2007
      • 1382

      #3
      I agree with Apis. It sounds like a dragging E-brake. Easy enough to determine, and fix.
      Or they used super-glue to seal up the leaks

      Comment

      • mrdoiron
        4th Gear
        • Dec 2009
        • 446

        #4
        Originally posted by Terrys
        I agree with Apis. It sounds like a dragging E-brake. Easy enough to determine, and fix.
        Or they used super-glue to seal up the leaks
        Thanks - it is certainly strange.
        I haven't noticed anything improve as she warms up, but then again I've not driven it far due to the lack of power/speed - only going to the home depot and back so far. I wasn't sue if I should drive it - or if that would potentially damage anything.... I'll take a few rounds around the block today and post back any findings.

        thanks for the input so far, appreciated

        mike
        ---------------------------
        1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
        1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
        1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
        1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
        1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
        2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
        2010 RR Sport Supercharged


        http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/

        Comment

        • SafeAirOne
          Overdrive
          • Apr 2008
          • 3435

          #5
          When you get back from Home Depot, is the handbrake drum too hot to touch, indicating dragging?

          Coincidentally, I suspect that this is a good way to overheat the seals and get them to leak.
          --Mark

          1973 SIII 109 RHD 2.5NA Diesel

          0-54mph in just under 11.5 minutes
          (9.7 minutes now that she's a 3-door).

          Comment

          • mrdoiron
            4th Gear
            • Dec 2009
            • 446

            #6
            Originally posted by SafeAirOne
            When you get back from Home Depot, is the handbrake drum too hot to touch, indicating dragging?

            Coincidentally, I suspect that this is a good way to overheat the seals and get them to leak.
            I just got back in from a ride, and reading this I ran out to feel the handbrake it it didn't seem hot...although it has been parked 5 mins not sure if could have cooled in that time.

            Two other things I noticed,
            1. definitely even less power on an incline
            2. the E-brake I tested while out, and it isn't holding very strong coincidentily as a smally declined surface with pulled full it still creeped forward..

            mike
            ---------------------------
            1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
            1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
            1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
            1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
            1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
            2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
            2010 RR Sport Supercharged


            http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/

            Comment

            • Apis Mellifera
              3rd Gear
              • Apr 2008
              • 386

              #7
              After the next drive feel each hub to see if for some reason the brakes are dragging. Also feel the u-joints on your new prop shaft. I asked about the cold/hot change because I have a friend with a IIa that runs very thick gear oil. He says there is a noticeable sluggishness on very cold mornings.

              There are a number of things that can cause a loss of power, so it's a matter of looking at the likely causes in each of the major systems and then narrowing it down from there. I'd still focus on the drive line from the TC since you had work done on that system and presumably it ran well before, but doesn't now.
              © 1974 Apis Mellifera. Few rights preserved.

              Comment

              • mrdoiron
                4th Gear
                • Dec 2009
                • 446

                #8
                Originally posted by Apis Mellifera
                After the next drive feel each hub to see if for some reason the brakes are dragging. Also feel the u-joints on your new prop shaft. I asked about the cold/hot change because I have a friend with a IIa that runs very thick gear oil. He says there is a noticeable sluggishness on very cold mornings.

                There are a number of things that can cause a loss of power, so it's a matter of looking at the likely causes in each of the major systems and then narrowing it down from there. I'd still focus on the drive line from the TC since you had work done on that system and presumably it ran well before, but doesn't now.
                I also dont know what gear oil they used, but I would think after initial sluggishness it would not be a big factor... yet it does stay the same...

                thanks,
                will go out later today again.
                ---------------------------
                1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
                1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
                1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
                1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
                1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
                2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
                2010 RR Sport Supercharged


                http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/

                Comment

                • albersj51
                  5th Gear
                  • May 2010
                  • 687

                  #9
                  Did it drive normally after the tranny seals were replaced, but before the new prop-shaft? I ask because, if the interim time it drove fine, then perhaps you can narrow it down to one component over the other....do you hear the engine working harder to get up to speed; almost as if its supplying the power (higher RPMS) but that power isnt making it to the wheels?

                  Comment

                  • LaneRover
                    Overdrive
                    • Oct 2006
                    • 1743

                    #10
                    This may be a bit too simple, but sometimes its that stuff that gets overlooked. Since they were working on the trannie and had to take out the tunnel and floorboards is there a chance that the floor mats (if you have them) didn't go back the way they came out and thus the gas pedal isn't going all the way to the floor?
                    1958 107 SW - Sold to a better home
                    1965 109 SW - nearly running well
                    1966 88 SW - running but needing attention
                    1969 109 P-UP

                    http://www.facebook.com/album.php?ai...2&l=64cfe23aa2

                    Comment

                    • mrdoiron
                      4th Gear
                      • Dec 2009
                      • 446

                      #11
                      Originally posted by LaneRover
                      This may be a bit too simple, but sometimes its that stuff that gets overlooked. Since they were working on the trannie and had to take out the tunnel and floorboards is there a chance that the floor mats (if you have them) didn't go back the way they came out and thus the gas pedal isn't going all the way to the floor?
                      Just checked...in a somewhat "shoot me sorta way" , but no, the rubber mat is flat to the floor.
                      I enclosed a couple pics for reference - it'll seem a little odd, as I added both a removable cross member to enable trans our bottom, as well as a roughly fab'd skid plate...

                      thanks for triage help...
                      Last edited by mrdoiron; 04-10-2011, 09:08 PM.
                      ---------------------------
                      1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
                      1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
                      1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
                      1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
                      1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
                      2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
                      2010 RR Sport Supercharged


                      http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/

                      Comment

                      • Howsomever
                        Low Range
                        • Jul 2010
                        • 23

                        #12
                        I would block the front wheels and jack up one rear wheel. With the transfer case in neutral what happens when you try to rotate the one wheel off the ground by hand?? It should turn freely.
                        Wayne

                        1963 Series IIA 88, with 122,000 miles
                        1984 D110, 3 door, 300Tdi, 127,000 miles

                        Comment

                        • bkreutz
                          4th Gear
                          • Apr 2010
                          • 408

                          #13
                          Going back to the gas pedal idea, might be a good idea to check and see if you're getting full throttle when the pedal is to the floor. What I'm thinking is that maybe they removed the pedal (for whatever reason) and didn't get it back in the same position so now you're only getting partial throttle when the pedal is to the floor. (unless they decided to retard your ignition timing in retaliation for making them work on the vehicle). HTH
                          Gale Breitkreutz
                          '03 Disco
                          '74 Series III 88 (sold, 4/13)
                          '47 CJ2A

                          Comment

                          • scatterling
                            1st Gear
                            • Dec 2006
                            • 183

                            #14
                            not sure if it matters but your propshaft is on backwards.
                            Neil Hanekom
                            '73 LHD 88
                            '75 FFR 109 exMOD Build Photo's
                            '99 D1

                            Comment

                            • mrdoiron
                              4th Gear
                              • Dec 2009
                              • 446

                              #15
                              Originally posted by scatterling
                              not sure if it matters but your propshaft is on backwards.
                              You know I wondered that, and not sure if it does matter either, but for sure will get them to reverse it when I take it back...

                              I check on the other suggestions - thanks
                              ---------------------------
                              1961 Ser IIa Hybrid Defender
                              1969 Ser IIa Bugeye
                              1980 Ser III Lightweight 24V RHD- sold
                              1988 LR90 turbo diesel RHD - currently frame off rebuild in progress
                              1998 Disco - ex wife :-(
                              2000 Disco - RIP , end over end 2.5 times
                              2010 RR Sport Supercharged


                              http://mikerovers.shutterfly.com/

                              Comment

                              Working...