Big trouble? Can't engage 3rd/4th. UPDATE POST 17

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SeriesShorty
    2nd Gear
    • Sep 2008
    • 275

    #16
    Thanks guys! Hoping for a break in the weather to get back out there again and do some more inspecting regarding the springs. I'm not feeling near as bad as I did when I first started this thread.

    Neil, make sure you don't take down those instructions on Picassa!
    1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
    1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

    Comment

    • SeriesShorty
      2nd Gear
      • Sep 2008
      • 275

      #17
      What'cha think of the guts?

      So I opened the gearbox up again and removed the forks. Using the wooden stick and hammer method I was able to free up 3rd/4th a bit. I can't see any missing or mangled synchro springs. Check out the two pics, the first is of the gear pushed as far rear as I could get it, the second is pushed as far forward as possible. I see a little rust in the area so that may have been blocking the movement originally. Anything else seem obviously out of place or to be concerned about?

      Is this enough movement to engage 3rd/4th? It moves a little less than 1/2" total from full front to full rear.

      Thanks for any advice!

      Store your photos and videos online with secure storage from Photobucket. Available on iOS, Android and desktop. Securely backup your memories and sign up today!


      Store your photos and videos online with secure storage from Photobucket. Available on iOS, Android and desktop. Securely backup your memories and sign up today!
      1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
      1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

      Comment

      • SafeAirOne
        Overdrive
        • Apr 2008
        • 3435

        #18
        Originally posted by SeriesShorty
        Is this enough movement to engage 3rd/4th? It moves a little less than 1/2" total from full front to full rear.
        That's not the full stroke. Have a look at the shift fork and shaft assembly. Now imagine how much the shift lever moves it when going from 3rd to 4th (or 1st to 2nd). Or, you might get your shift lever and move it the distance it usually takes to shift from 3rd to 4th, then observe the distance that the lower part of the shift lever below the pivot ball moves. The synchro assembly must travel about that same distance.
        --Mark

        1973 SIII 109 RHD 2.5NA Diesel

        0-54mph in just under 11.5 minutes
        (9.7 minutes now that she's a 3-door).

        Comment

        • knac1234
          4th Gear
          • Nov 2010
          • 442

          #19
          FWIW definitely more than a 1/2". I had to push rather hard using my fingers to move it back and forth.

          Good luck...
          Julian
          Julian
          72 Series III NAS
          03 Disco
          04 Freelander (sold, but still running strong)
          2011 LR2 (Fuji White/Tan....per the wife )
          65 MGB / 73 MGBGT
          71 RHD Hillman Super Imp

          Comment

          • SeriesShorty
            2nd Gear
            • Sep 2008
            • 275

            #20
            Had a few minutes to get back on it tonight. I whacked the synchro pretty good with a wood dowel and hammer and that's all I can get it to move. I was afraid to really pound it too good for fear of causing more damage.

            Any other thoughts?
            1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
            1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

            Comment

            • SeriesShorty
              2nd Gear
              • Sep 2008
              • 275

              #21
              Played around some more today and learned how to rotate the syncho around so I could check for all the clips. Is this my problem?
              1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
              1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

              Comment

              • scatterling
                1st Gear
                • Dec 2006
                • 183

                #22
                that's probably it. It looks like the spring might have broken and/or twisted out of it's seated position, thereby not allowing the synchro to move. Can you see the other two springs? Are they still in place?
                Neil Hanekom
                '73 LHD 88
                '75 FFR 109 exMOD Build Photo's
                '99 D1

                Comment

                • cousindave
                  1st Gear
                  • Jan 2007
                  • 192

                  #23
                  That's it! You might be able to get the spring back in with a screw driver then she should shift easily. Mine is missing one spring and she still shifts well. But since you are this far might as well replace all three. Good luck!

                  Comment

                  • SeriesShorty
                    2nd Gear
                    • Sep 2008
                    • 275

                    #24
                    Sweet! I am sooooo smiling right now.

                    Actually, 2 out of the 3 are twisted out of place. Thank you again Neil for posting the link to the instructions showing me how to rotate the synchro to see that they weren't all seated the same. I had merely acknowledged that all the springs were there...not that they were correct.

                    Today is our last day of good weather again for a while so I'll be back at it when we have another break. Oh how I've loved the last couple days of 60F weather!
                    1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
                    1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

                    Comment

                    • SeriesShorty
                      2nd Gear
                      • Sep 2008
                      • 275

                      #25
                      So I've got all 3 clips out. Should the synchro be able to move at this point? I've read several old posts that state that some people were able to drive just fine missing clips. With all 3 out my synchro can still only be moved forward about 3/8". I'm hoping there isn't anything more to my problem.

                      Also, for folks who have replace their clips in-situ, what size angled needle nose pliers did you use? I got a long set that has a 90 degree bend at the end, and the bent part is about an inch long. It's almost impossible to reach inside through the top and get a good angle. Surely there is a degree/tip length that works best...

                      Thanks!
                      1966 IIa - ex-MOD, ex-FFR, ex-24v
                      1997 Discovery SE7 - I'm empty inside without her

                      Comment

                      • cousindave
                        1st Gear
                        • Jan 2007
                        • 192

                        #26
                        I have my transmission out right now. I' ll look tomorrow to see. Right now I have two clips in and I can shift between third and fourth easily just using my fingers

                        Comment

                        • Apis Mellifera
                          3rd Gear
                          • Apr 2008
                          • 386

                          #27
                          Give the gears a little spin as you're trying to move the syncro. It's been a while since I replaced the springs, but I seem to recall the syncro being hard to slide back and forth. I fitted the springs in situ and used only a flat screw driver and a long pick with a 90 I bought at Harbor Freight. This has to be one of the most fiddly jobs on a Series.
                          © 1974 Apis Mellifera. Few rights preserved.

                          Comment

                          • knac1234
                            4th Gear
                            • Nov 2010
                            • 442

                            #28
                            Seriesshorty--

                            Here are the pliers I bought at Autozone 2 weeks ago when I did mine. I cannot say they are the correct or best ones, but along with scraped up hands and a couple of hours I was able to get my one clip in with them!

                            http://www.autozone.com/autozone/acc...ier=914140_0_0_

                            I did use a very small screwdriver also, like Apis says, once my clip was almost all the way in.....holding the clip with those pliers I pushed forward with the flat screwdriver blade.

                            Good luck!

                            Julian
                            Julian
                            72 Series III NAS
                            03 Disco
                            04 Freelander (sold, but still running strong)
                            2011 LR2 (Fuji White/Tan....per the wife )
                            65 MGB / 73 MGBGT
                            71 RHD Hillman Super Imp

                            Comment

                            Working...